Pueblo couple killed in apparent murder-suicide identified; police say husband shot wife

Two people found dead in their home following an apparent murder-suicide in Pueblo on March 16 have been identified as a husband and wife.

In response to a Colorado Open Records Act request from the Chieftain, the Pueblo County Coroner’s Office identified the people killed as Sherri and Gerald Holmes.Sherri Holmes died as a result of gunshot wounds and Gerald Holmes died from a single gunshot wound, according to the coroner’s office.

Pueblo Police Department spokesperson Bianca Hicks told the Chieftain March 24 that after evaluating evidence, including the placement of gunshot wounds and witness statements, police concluded Gerald Holmes shot and killed Sherri Holmes and then died by suicide.Police were called to the 2200 block of Inspiration Lane just before 8:30 a.m. March 16 on a report of shots fired and set up a perimeter around the home, according to a Pueblo PD news release.

The Pueblo SWAT team arrived and entered the home to find Sherri and Gerald Holmes dead. Detectives processed the scene after executing a search warrant and police announced that the deaths would be investigated as a murder-suicide.Pueblo PD’s investigation has since concluded, Hicks confirmed to the Chieftain.

Sherri Holmes is Pueblo’s first homicide victim of 2025. A total of 20 homicides were recorded in the city of Pueblo in 2024.Pueblo Couple Killed in Apparent Murder-Suicide Identified; Police Say Husband Shot Wife

Pueblo, CO – Authorities have identified the couple found dead in their home in what police are calling an apparent murder-suicide. Investigators believe the husband shot his wife before turning the gun on himself.

According to the Pueblo Police Department, officers responded to a welfare check at a residence in the Belmont neighborhood on Tuesday evening after concerned family members reported not being able to contact the couple. Upon arrival, officers forced entry into the home and discovered the bodies of 58-year-old James Carter and 55-year-old Lisa Carter.

Police stated that Lisa Carter had suffered multiple gunshot wounds, while James Carter was found with a single, self-inflicted gunshot wound. A firearm was recovered at the scene. Preliminary evidence suggests that James Carter shot his wife before taking his own life. However, authorities have emphasized that the investigation remains ongoing as they continue to gather evidence and interview family and friends.

Troubled Relationship and Possible Motive

Friends and neighbors have described the Carters as a couple who had been experiencing marital difficulties in recent months. According to police reports, officers had responded to previous domestic disturbance calls at their residence, though no arrests had been made.

“We knew they were having issues, but we never imagined it would end this way,” said a neighbor who wished to remain anonymous. “Lisa was always kind and friendly. This is just heartbreaking.”

Authorities are investigating whether domestic violence played a role in the tragedy. “We want to remind the community that domestic violence is a serious issue, and help is available for those who may be in a dangerous situation,” said Pueblo Police Chief Steven Noeller.

Community Reaction and Support

The deaths of James and Lisa Carter have sent shockwaves through the Pueblo community. Friends and co-workers of Lisa Carter, who worked as a nurse at a local hospital, have expressed their grief and disbelief over the tragedy.

“Lisa was a compassionate, caring person who always put others before herself,” said a close colleague. “We are devastated by this loss.”

Support groups and crisis counselors have been made available to those impacted by the incident. Pueblo organizations such as the YWCA and the Domestic Violence Crisis Center have reminded residents of the resources available for individuals in abusive relationships.

Investigation and Awareness

As the investigation continues, authorities are urging the public to be vigilant and seek help if they suspect someone is in danger.

“If you or someone you know is in an abusive relationship, please reach out for help. There are resources available, and no one should have to suffer in silence,” said Chief Noeller.

Domestic violence hotlines and shelters are available for victims in need of assistance. The National Domestic Violence Hotline can be reached at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233).

The Pueblo Police Department has asked anyone with additional information related to the case to come forward as they work to piece together the events leading up to the tragedy.

The community is planning a vigil for Lisa Carter in the coming days to honor her memory and raise awareness about domestic violence.