5 Creepiest Places Near Niagara Falls
5 Creepiest Places Near Niagara Falls You Should Never Visit Alone
Niagara Falls is world-renowned for its stunning natural beauty, thundering waters, and romantic honeymoon getaways. But beyond the postcard-perfect views and touristy charm, there’s a darker, more mysterious side that most visitors never see. Shadowed by ghost stories, historic tragedies, and eerie legends, Niagara and its surrounding towns hold secrets that will send a chill down your spine.
If you’re the type who loves the thrill of a good scare, here are five of the creepiest places near Niagara Falls that come with a warning: Don’t go alone.
—
1. The Screaming Tunnel – Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario
Tucked away near Warner Road, just a few minutes from Niagara Falls, lies the infamous Screaming Tunnel. It may look like an ordinary, graffiti-covered passage beneath a railroad line, but its legend is the stuff of nightmares.
According to local lore, over a century ago, a young girl fled from a nearby farmhouse, engulfed in flames, and ran into the tunnel seeking help. She died there, screaming in agony. To this day, it’s said that if you stand in the tunnel at midnight and light a match, you’ll hear her scream — and the flame will be mysteriously extinguished.
Visitors report sudden temperature drops, strange whispers, and unexplained sensations. Some even claim to see ghostly figures watching from the shadows.
Why it’s creepy: The pitch-black tunnel has no lights, no exit signs, and no explanation for the noises people hear. It’s a magnet for paranormal investigators — and urban legends.
—
2. Oakwood Cemetery – Niagara Falls, New York
Dating back to 1852, Oakwood Cemetery is more than just a resting place for the dead — it’s also the final destination for some of Niagara Falls’ most notorious figures, including Annie Edson Taylor, the first person to go over the Falls in a barrel and survive.
This sprawling graveyard is known for its unusual quiet — so quiet, in fact, that it unsettles even the bravest visitors. Reports of shadowy figures, phantom footsteps, and disembodied voices are common. Some even say they’ve seen a woman in 1800s dress walking slowly between the gravestones… and then vanishing into thin air.
Why it’s creepy: Cemeteries can be peaceful during the day, but Oakwood turns unsettling after dusk. Locals avoid it at night — and ghost hunters are obsessed with it.
—
3. Fort George – Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario
Fort George was a critical military post during the War of 1812. Bloody battles, disease, and death plagued this site, and today it’s considered one of the most haunted places in Canada.
By day, Fort George offers historical reenactments and educational tours. But by night, it becomes something else entirely. Staff and guests alike report strange occurrences: doors opening on their own, chilling cold spots, ghostly soldiers pacing in full uniform, and even children’s laughter echoing through the empty barracks.
There’s one spirit who’s gained notoriety — a little girl seen in the Officer’s Quarters, who vanishes when approached.
Why it’s creepy: It’s one thing to hear about haunted forts. It’s another to stand inside one, in the dark, surrounded by spirits of war and grief.
—
4. The Tunnel Under Lockport – Lockport, New York
A short drive from Niagara Falls, the Lockport Cave and Underground Boat Ride offers a look into the old industrial canal system built in the 1800s. But what many don’t know is how eerie and unnerving the place really is.
Originally dug by hand by immigrant laborers, the tunnels were dangerous, dark, and deadly. Many workers died during its construction — and some believe their souls never left. Strange noises echo through the limestone corridors: tapping, whispers, and the occasional blood-curdling scream.
Guests report seeing apparitions, particularly near the underground boat ride section, where the water flows silently — as if holding secrets from long ago.
Why it’s creepy: You’re underground, in the dark, floating through an old canal where people died. It’s tight, damp, and hauntingly still.
—
5. Drummond Hill Cemetery – Niagara Falls, Ontario
One of the bloodiest battles in Canadian history took place here: the Battle of Lundy’s Lane in 1814. Thousands of soldiers died on this very hill, and many are buried beneath your feet when you visit Drummond Hill Cemetery.
Today, it’s a historic landmark — but also a hotspot for paranormal activity. People describe seeing soldiers wandering among the graves, hearing war cries and gunfire in the middle of the night, and experiencing deep feelings of sorrow or dread that come out of nowhere.
Some ghost tours that stop here include thermal camera footage and EVP (Electronic Voice Phenomena) recordings that suggest something — or someone — is still lingering.
Why it’s creepy: It’s not just one or two ghosts; it’s the energy of a whole battle echoing through time.
—
Final Thoughts: Are You Brave Enough?
Niagara Falls is more than just a romantic escape or a natural wonder — it’s a place filled with mystery, legend, and spirits that refuse to rest. Whether you’re a ghost hunter or just someone looking for a thrill, these locations will scratch that paranormal itch — but consider this your warning: Don’t go alone.
The next time you’re in Niagara, skip the souvenir shops for a night and explore its darker side. Just don’t be surprised if something follows you home.
